The Seeds – Fallin’ Off The Edge (1977)
Artist: The Seeds
Title: Fallin’ Off The Edge
Year: 1977
Format: LP
Label: GNP Crescendo
Although they didn’t possess the talent of either the Blues Magoos or Iron Butterfly, their closest stylistic kin, the Seeds managed to carve out a multi-album career and a devoted cult following on the basis of Sky Saxon’s adenoidal flower-punk angst. The band’s charm lies in its direct style, which is all the more compelling due to the group’s amateurishness.
It works because the Seeds were brutally honest. Unlike the Godz, whose amateurishness seemed like an affectation arising out of lack of desire, the Seeds’ awkward music appeared to have its genesis in a genuine lack of talent. Iron Butterfly, the Magoos, and even the Godz, whether through maturity, practice, or lineup fluctuations, all eventually arrived at a more accomplished sound. The Seeds never did. From the opening notes of “Can’t Seem to Make You Mine” on their debut, one sensed that this was as good as this band was ever going to be.
So why issue this compilation of alternates and out-takes for such a limited quartet? Because Fallin’ Off the Edge, like all the Seeds’ albums, is a study in the potency of desire. This was a group that wasn’t gonna let a little thing like lack of talent stand in the way of being a kick-ass rock and roll band! The Seeds were pure, raw, infectious energy, and each of their admittedly flawed efforts is a delight. Even this posthumous hodgepodge is a worthwhile listen.
In fact, there’s more variation here than we’ve come to expect. In addition to the sinister undertones of “The Wind Blows Your Hair”, the sneering “Nobody Spoil My Fun”, and the frenzied “She’s Wrong”, the group tackles bluesy rockabilly (“Pretty Girl”, complete with jerry Lee Lewis-style glissandos), novelty (“Daisy Mae”, which sounds like a throwaway from a bad Elvis movie), and even country (the title track). Granted, they don’t play these styles any better than they do their usual fare, but give them credit for being adventurous.
Ending on a version of their best known song (“Pushin’ Too Hard”), which is only superficially different from the original, it’s clear that this package was never meant to be revelatory. The point is that the Seeds even put their soul into material that wasn’t originally targeted for release. That, my friends, is what defines a kick-ass rock and roll band! (ochsfan RYM)
Track Listing
- The Wind Blows Your Hair
- The Other Place
- She’s Wrong
- Nobody Spoil My Fun
- Fallin’ Off The Edge (Of My Mind)
- Pretty Girl
- Tripmaker
- Chocolate River
- Daisy Mae
- The Wind Blows Your Hair
- Pushin’ Too Hard



If you like the 1960s punk/garage stylings of The Seeds then you will like this album.I was really into this type of music in the 1960s and that is reflected by the singles I bought back in the day (eg. The Standells,The Sonics,Richard and the Young Lions,Blues Magoos,Paul Revere and the Raiders etc.).I really like the country styling of the title track.Sky Saxon RIP.Thanks to Leonard.
The Seeds are who they are and that’s why I love them…as I did this recording. Sky was unique in his vocals style and doesn’t fail on this one…Loved it…