Whalefeathers – Whalefeathers (1970)
Title: Whalefeathers
Year: 1970
Format: LP
Label: Blue Horizon
It has taken me quite a few spins to really absorb this Ohio band’s sophomore and final release. Like with the Black Cat Bones lp, continuous, strong bluesy overtones tend to drain me, my mind wandering off more so than with something hard or progressive to keep me riveted and rockin’ the place.
I blame it on the unhurried methodical pace that envelopes three out of five blues-predisposed melodies, and as a result of that pace many of those pieces or ‘bassy plod over a slow emotional solo’ seem derivative of the last blue-based project I’ve heard. Either that or the blues influence they are playing with isn’t bursting with originality.
Apparently the quintet’s 1970 debut, Declare, is heavier rock and less blues with both having wisps of psych meandering through them, but until I track it down all we have to go on is the self-titled lp.
Mingling both musical worlds is the lp’s opener, a cover of Cream’s “World Of Pain” with a beefier, elongated start, keyboard-laden mid-section and a short drum solo thrown in for good measure. This is just in time for the other cover tune on the original album, a more feverish version of “I Don’t Need No Doctor” by Ray Charles, which had already been reworked by Chocolate Watch Band and would be later by New Riders of the Purple Sage, Humble Pie and a slew of other bands.
Fact of the matter is the few songs on this lp that are actually Whalefeathers’s own material sound like they could be refurbished tracks with longer instrumental nooks and additional ditties inserted here and there, especially the organ-ingrained “It’s a Hard Road (Back Home)” with its polite gospel-esque melody and chorus.
From there the more soft-spoken “Bastich”, this time I believe a cover song by the oddball band Saint Steven (see June 29, 2010 post), condones a ballad-like vocal approach that comes off rather one-dimensional and blah, then suddenly lights the way for more heartfelt sentiment as soon as the band finds the ignition switch.
“Oh, Pretty Woman” is perhaps the liveliest and shortest track of the bunch with a clandestinely combative rhythm and some dominant soloing, meanwhile a somewhat spacey/psyche organ intro leisurely welcomes the more progressive “Shadows” to the family where keyboards and solos spin an imaginative web within each other.
The bluesy aspect remains present, just not overwhelming me to sleep. As for the clean, unobscured vocals, only at the start of “Bastich” did I feel they failed to nail the sound, otherwise they merge with the music quite snugly. (blackcatbone RYM)
Track Listing
- World Of Pain
- I Don’t Need No Doctor
- It’s A Hard Road (Back Home)
- Bastich
- Pretty Woman
- Shadows


thanks!
this looks promising am looking forward to hearing it one day.
just dragged this out for a listen again, not half bad, lots of swirly organ and fuzz, good strong vocals, but definitely blues based. had my copy with 2 bonus tracks for about 7 years. my opinion (for what it’s worth)- if you dig bluesy rock get your fists on a copy. cheers from Oz.
My personal opinion might just differ from everyone elses. Quite frankly, I have heard both albums and I cannot see for the best of me how in the world these are so highly rated amongst collectors?
First off, the music isn’t really too distinctive and there are other indie or private pressings out there that are way better featured in Acid Archives than this piece. Second off, the vocals just fall flat and are at times seemingly out of key!
The music is okay, but frankly, a little too way overblown than what some people make it out to be……..
My final analysis of both of the Whalefeathers releases are: Don’t pick these albums up unless you are a die hard Psych and Prog Rock collector, otherwise all these will end up being is space fillers to occupy your shelf!
Frankly, I would play these probably just one time and then put them back up on the shelf! I may come off being harsh or perhaps overtly critical, but these are most certainly overrated!! For the cost of original albums being way over $40.00 in NM condition on the collectors market, these are most certainly NOT worth the cost of admission!
Trust me, if you are that desperate to hear what these sound like, either go to a download torrent, You Tube or just try to find a used cheap ass bootleg on Ebay, Gemm, or MusicStack……….
RecordFanatic
Hello RecordFanatic,
I think one of the reasons people shell out big bucks for these albums is for the collecting itself, and there’s lots of reasons for that (LP cover art, record label etc.) my theory has to be part true because many of these albums have been re-released and people still spend big dollars on original copie. Take the Mainstream Records label for instance, their whole psych catalogue has been re-released for the cheap but no one seems to buy them. It’s just like any other collectable and the “got to have it” attitude.
Indeed, a collector doesn’t buy records for the music only. I have so many LPs that are still sealed; it’s just part of the collecting fever. After all, do stamps collectors stick their items on envelopes???
Hello Raul,
Good point!!!
Weird, then I guess I must be a one-of-a-kind-collector? I frankly cannot see the point as to why people would shell out the cash for something that is musically shitty, let it sit upon a shelf , only to collect dust! But, then again, that’s just me and my opinion.
The way I collect records is that I am in this for the music mainly and not a sport! I play my records, which to me is what they are initially meant for in the first place.
For me to spend over $200.00 for one record, it had better be damned good!! I will tell you that the one record I probably spent the most money on was Yesterday’s Children on Map City records. Why? Because it was actually a musically great record and the vocals were awesome. Also, I was able to transfer this NM copy to a CD for future playing, and preserve the historical relevance of this classic! I felt this to be a wise investment for something I will definitely use!
Who can deny that the Yesterday’s Children is a killer record? Hands down, nobody! No wonder that record has earned it’s reputation! It is that good!
RecordFanatic
Yes, Recordfanatic, we disagree about what a collector is.
For instance, there are people who collect all releases on a certain label; or all records by a particular artist; of course, they’re not all masterpieces.
I can tell you that I spent big money on items that are still sealed decades later.
Raul,
there is actually no disagreement as to what a record collector is. Whatever you want it to be is based upon your perception. It is just that I would rather have a solid collection of 5,000 albums I can listen to, than to have 5,000 more that just sit there as trophies, just to say: “Hey, look at what I got”! In the end, you reach your goal materially of having that one extra piece in your collection, but musically it is less fulfilling if you’re not listening to it!
When I started collecting records, it was for the music. More times often than not, it does in fact become an anal retentive obsession, being less and less about the music! The goal that you started off with now has been replaced for this trophy quest, that not only is an expensive one, but also takes up a lot of unnecessary space! At this point, when it is no longer about music, it becomes an obsessive association that you currently have with the object, then you have forgotten the original reason why you even own it!
I used to have about 10,000 records myself total at one time, and was exactly just like you Raul. I came to discover that I had all of these records in my possession that I was not listening to and in fact, I had so many that I couldn’t any longer admire them. Finally, as hard as it was for me, I had to accept the reality to come to terms with myself. What am I doing this for, if I cannot enjoy what I have and never play it? So, with much thought, I got rid of 5,000 albums out of the 10,000 that I owned, and now that I am back to collecting records again for what they are meant to be used for, I am actually more happy as a result!
The reason why I got rid of the 5,000 records out of the 10,000 I owned, was that they were just trophies that musically sucked! Now I am just happy that my collection is solid!
So, you might ask me, do I still collect records? Yes I do, but it is for the music, not the value or as a trophy. The other question would be, do I consider myself a record collector? Yes, maybe perhaps not in the traditional sense like you Raul, but yes I am still a collector, just rehabilitated!
Today, my head is more level. I have a certain set budget every month and my priorities are set as far as what I want to collect versus the obsessive need for it! I used to take my work lunch money to save it and buy records. I owned two pairs of jeans, underwear, socks and shirts.. This was just to support my collecting habits! Was that bad? Yes. Is there worse than me? You betcha there is! They are called pack rats and I was pretty damn close to getting there too
I am collector of records and not just out of the need to have them there. How do you define what a record collector is? I don’t know and I don’t care. Does it necessarily matter anyway?
I don’t care about the value of money or how much the object is worth. The music should be the main objective, not the object! So, what does it matter anyway if you have sealed records that you spent huge $$$$ on, when you are just going to die anyway never enjoying any one of them for the music.
Regardless, I may be of a different breed than others here, but at the same time, I don’t any longer buy things that I am not going to use, regardless of price! Nuff said!
RecordFanatic
I’m from their hometown, Cincinnati and listened to them live, but never got their albums.
thanks!
Hi from Cy
WHALEFEATHERS – 1970
This medium priced ‘rarity’ in the UK collecting market, is just about worth the price of entry….the six tracks take one on a journey through a ‘steady as you go’ world of the bloooze…though not a lot of originality is on show….and some of the longer tracks take effort to keep listening…..however, I cannot fault this album….as it will reward more than one listen, however, out there, there are so many other albums that command more attention than what’s on show here…..if you like your guitar based bands, then you will surely find something to delight.
This is not in anyway a ‘bag of tricks’…it is what it is….blues for bluesers….enthusiasts, “form an orderly queue please”!
Thanks for the share,
Cy at Pck