A Foot In Cold Water – The Second Foot In Cold Water (1973)
Title: The Second Foot In Cold Water
Year: 1973
Format: LP
Label: Dafodil
A Foot in Coldwater was formed in Toronto in 1970 from three bands. Leggat, Taylor, and Horne had been members of Nucleus, and the Lords of London. Machin and Naumann were in the band Island. Together, they signed with Daffodil Records, which coined the group’s name.The band’s first album, A Foot in Coldwater, was released in 1972 with their first single “(Make Me Do) Anything You Want” reaching top 25 in the Canadian charts.
In 1973, they released their second album The Second Foot in Coldwater which included moderately successful singles “(Isn’t Love Unkind) In My Life” (#34) and “Love is Coming” (#27). In 1974, the band released a third album, All Around Us, which included a shorter version of “(Make Me Do) Anything You Want” which again made the Canadian singles chart.
The band released one more single, “Midnight Lady” before Daffodil Records filed for bankruptcy in 1975, leaving them without a label. Horne left the group and the remaining members recorded a single, “Breaking Through” for Anthem in 1977, but it was not a success and the band folded.The following year, Hughie Leggat teamed up with his brother Gordon and assembled a new band, calling themselves Private Eye.
Their eponymous debut album was released in 1979 and featured the hit ‘Your Place or Mine’ (#51). The album itself peaked at #59. In early 1980, a 2nd single ‘Changes’ reached #93. Due to lack of support from their label, the band called it quits in 1981 and the Leggat brothers along with Rob Sagar, Phil Sullivan and Danny Taylor formed a new project called Leggat. This union produced one album Illuminations which was released in 1982.
The song White Flags received airplay but the album was generally poorly received due to the length of the songs (most were over 4 minutes). White Flags was also covered by Blue Öyster Cult.A Foot in Coldwater regrouped in 1988 for short tours, and in 1998 Unidisc reissued their first three albums plus a two-disc compilation The Very Best of a Foot in Coldwater.
A Foot in Coldwater was formed in Toronto in 1970 from three bands. Leggat, Taylor, and Horne had been members of Nucleus, and the Lords of London. Machin and Naumann were in the band Island. Together, they signed with Daffodil Records, which coined the group’s name.
The band’s first album, A Foot in Coldwater, was released in 1972 with their first single “(Make Me Do) Anything You Want” reaching top 25 in the Canadian charts. In 1973, they released their second album The Second Foot in Coldwater which included moderately successful singles “(Isn’t Love Unkind) In My Life” (#34) and “Love is Coming” (#27). In 1974, the band released a third album, All Around Us, which included a shorter version of “(Make Me Do) Anything You Want” which again made the Canadian singles chart.
The band released one more single, “Midnight Lady” before Daffodil Records filed for bankruptcy in 1975, leaving them without a label. Horne left the group and the remaining members recorded a single, “Breaking Through” for Anthem in 1977, but it was not a success and the band folded.
The following year, Hughie Leggat teamed up with his brother Gordon and assembled a new band, calling themselves Private Eye. Their eponymous debut album was released in 1979 and featured the hit ‘Your Place or Mine’ (#51). The album itself peaked at #59. In early 1980, a 2nd single ‘Changes’ reached #93.
Due to lack of support from their label, the band called it quits in 1981 and the Leggat brothers along with Rob Sagar, Phil Sullivan and Danny Taylor formed a new project called Leggat. This union produced one album Illuminations which was released in 1982. The song White Flags received airplay but the album was generally poorly received due to the length of the songs (most were over 4 minutes). White Flags was also covered by Blue Öyster Cult.
A Foot in Coldwater regrouped in 1988 for short tours, and in 1998 Unidisc reissued their first three albums plus a two-disc compilation The Very Best of a Foot in Coldwater. (Wikipedia)
“Damn good rock n’ roll. This bands stuff is semi-mainstream hard AOR with some really strong progressive tendencies. Features great playing from everyone, but the duel guitars and organ stand out. Some would call this stuff “pomp rock”, and I love it!” (thirstymoon RYM)
Track Listing
- Coming Is Love
- So Long
- Suzy
- How Much Can You Take
- (Isn’t Love Unkind) In My Life
- Sailing Ships
- Love Is Coming


This is a pretty good lp Leonard. I like your new format because I like to read the reviews and comments. Thanks.
Yup, I do agree Leonerd with Mike. This is actually a great band with a couple of other great albums on the Daffodil records label based in Canada. For me though, the earlier, the better for A Foot In Cold Water.
This is one of those opportunities that I would take to say that the music actually equals that of the value of the price tag……….
RecordFanatic
It’s always amused me to read that “How Much Can You Take” was never released as a single form this album; that’s *clearly* the standout track, and and undiscovered hard rock banger.
I have a Canadian copy of the album, with the original (nude-ish) cover.
Have the first by this band but wasn’t aware of any others…sounds like it might be worth finding.
Leonard:
Another great Canadian Band. They reunited for a show on April 8 at the Sound Academy here in Toronto.
Hey James,
“How Much Can You Take” was released as a single, it is the flip side of the “Love Is Coming” single.
The single actually shows both songs as the “A” side.
The catalog number was DFS 1040, it was released in either August or September 1973. Track length is 3:12, i.e. an edited version of the album version,.The second part of the bridge was edited out, making the bridge sound unresloved.
Hello Ross,
If you have any info on the show, please pass it along.
I’m hearing post Joe Walsh James Gang…must be the Canadian heritage…
Hi!
Just wondering….still able to ****load from this site? If so, not sure where to locate the file. Please advise.
Thanx!
Ciao! For now.
rntcj