Skip to content

April 29, 2010

Smoke Rise – The Survival of St. Joan (A Rock Opera) (1971)

Smoke Rise – The Survival of St. Joan (A Rock Opera) (1971)
Artist: Smoke Rise
Title: The Survival of St. Joan (A Rock Opera)
Year: 1971
Format: LP
Label: Paramount

The Survival of St. Joan is a rock opera by Smoke Rise (Gary Ruffin, Hank Ruffin, Stan Ruffin, and Randy Bugg–music composed by Hank and Gary) on a libretto by James Lineberger. To date, it has not been issued on compact disc. It was first produced as a concept album on Paramount Records PAS-9000 by Stephen Schwartz in 1971.

A concert version ran eight performances at The Playwrights Unit. A fully-scripted musical play with spoken dialogue, directed by Chuck Gnys was produced at the Studio Arena Theatre in Buffalo, New York, November 5, 1970. It had 16 performances Off-off-Broadway at the Anderson Theater, directed by Gnys and produced by Haila Stoddard and Neal Du Brock, where audiences were frequently scared off by the local chapter of the Hells Angels in the front rows each night.

Possibly inspired by Operation Shepherdess: The Mystery of Joan of Arc by André Guérin and Jack Palmer White, a revisionist history alleging that Joan of Arc escaped execution and later married a nobleman named Robert des Armoises, an idea rejected by historians [1], and certainly inspired by the Vietnam War, the opera tells of the government of France and Pierre Cauchon, Archbishop of Beauvais releasing Joan of Arc and allowing a double, also believed to be a witch, to burn in her place. She is sent to live with a mute farmer, who falls in love with her, as he elucidates in songs performed in soliloquy toward the audience. Realizing that there is no end in sight to the Hundred Years’ War, the first act ends with Joan seeking to rejoin the army, despite the fact that she is no longer hearing her voices.

In Act II, Joan learns that she has lost the respect of the army, who attempt to rape her. (The libretto in the concept album has her get raped about halfway through the act; this was changed when stagings went beyond a band performance to a full-fledged play.) She meets with a deserter who no longer understands the purpose of the war, unless it is God’s desire to reduce the population, as well as civilians affected by the war’s rationing, complaining that the general can have whatever he wants, whether or not he needs it. Alone and unappreciated, Joan is eventually found by villagers who mistakenly decide she has put a hex on their cow, who tie her to a tree and immolate her, thus her life ends almost as history tells us it did. Upon her death, she re-establishes contact with her three voices, St. Michael, St. Catherine, and St. Margaret.

The play script is held in the North Carolina Collection at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and remains unpublished. It contains many scene changes, often depicting how ordinary people’s lives affect the war, including Joan’s brother, Charles, acting as a scribe for his mother, requesting the king to provide them Joan’s soldier wages to live on, and chides her for some irate informalisms she wants to include. (Wikipedia)

Track Listing

  1. Survival
  2. Someone Is Dying
  3. Run, Run
  4. Back In The World
  5. I’m Here / Love Me
  6. Stonefire
  7. Love Me
  8. Lady Of Light
  9. Country Life
  10. Run, Run / Precious Mommy
  11. Medley: Survival / Run, Run / Back In The World
  12. Lonely Neighbors
  13. Cornbread
  14. This Is How It Is
  15. Cannonfire
  16. It’s Over
  17. Darkwoods Lullaby
  18. You Don’t Know Why
  19. Propitius
  20. Burning A Witch
  21. Love Me
Read more from Rock
« The Grass Roots – The Grass Roots (1975)Locomotive – Locomotive (1969) »
4 Comments
  1. Jul 23 2010

    Ok.

  2. Dennis Dahlstrom
    Feb 27 2012

    The biggest problem I can see with this album is it was never made available on CD. I have had 4 copies to date, and still get moved by the harmonies and music. I think the timing was off for Smoke Rise. There have been countless recordings by other bands with more success, an d much less talent

  3. J. J. Reis
    Oct 24 2013

    I think this is a very good album. In my opinion, the Ruffin bros. & Mr. Bugg may be embarrassed by their past effort and have blocked all attempts to have this work released on compact disc or any other carrier medium in the past or in the future. I found a mp3@320 bp/s download several years ago, where each LP side is one mp3 track each on my CD-R. I listen to that whenever I’m in the mood for this St. Joan.

  4. J. J. Reis
    Oct 24 2013

    I think this is a very good album.

Reader comments above are preserved from the 2009–2015 redtelephone66.com archive.